Champagne, Crémant, Cava or Prosecco: Which Bubbles for Christmas?
Every bottle with bubbles gets called "Champagne" at Christmas. But Champagne, Crémant, Cava and Prosecco are made in different places, in different ways, and taste different. The price gap between them is big, too.
Here's what sets them apart, which one to open when, and the family producers we buy each one from.
The difference in one minute
| Style | Where | How the bubbles get there | Tastes like | Ours from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Champagne | Champagne, France | Second fermentation in the bottle; at least 15 months' ageing | Toast, brioche, red apple, fine bubbles | €56 |
| Crémant | Other French regions, such as Limoux | Same bottle method; at least 9 months' ageing | Crisp apple, citrus, a creamy mousse | €32.50 |
| Cava | Mainly Catalonia, Spain | Same bottle method; at least 9 months' ageing | Green apple, citrus, a dry, nutty edge | €29 |
| Prosecco | North-east Italy | Second fermentation in a large tank | Pear, peach, flowers; softer, frothier bubbles | €18 |
The bottle method (the "traditional method") gives finer bubbles and toasty, bready flavours from time on the yeast. The tank method keeps Prosecco fresh, fruity and easy-going.
Champagne: for the big moment
J. Charpentier is a family Champagne house in Villers-sous-Châtillon, in the Marne valley. It's well away from the famous names of Reims and Épernay, and their Champagnes lean on Pinot Meunier for rich, fruity depth.
- J. Charpentier Brut Réserve, €56. Toast, red apple and a fine mousse. Our everyday Champagne.
- J. Charpentier Brut Prestige Rosé, €65.50. Red berries and a pale blush. A showstopper for New Year's Eve.
- J. Charpentier Millésime 2019, €91. From a single great year. The one for a milestone.
- J. Charpentier Brut Réserve Magnum, €112. Twelve to sixteen glasses, and nothing makes an entrance like a magnum.
Crémant: Champagne quality, about half the price
Crémant is made exactly like Champagne, just elsewhere in France. Limoux, in the hills of the south-west, has a strong claim to be where it all started: records show monks at the Abbey of Saint-Hilaire making sparkling wine there in 1531. The Antech family have made it in Limoux for generations, and Françoise Antech runs the estate today.
- Antech 'Eugénie' Crémant de Limoux, €32.50. Fine, dry and elegant. Our pick with smoked salmon.
- Antech 'Emotion' Rosé Crémant de Limoux, €32.95. Mostly Chardonnay, with a delicate pink colour and red fruit.
- Antech 'M' Blanquette de Limoux, €32.50. From the local Mauzac grape, with a gentle apple flavour.
Cava: the crowd-pleaser
Carles Andreu Cava Brut Reserva, €29. Made by the traditional method, with green apple, citrus and a crisp, dry finish. It's our go-to when the house is full, and it holds its bubbles well in a punch bowl.
Prosecco: light, fruity and fun
- San Simone 'Veste' Prosecco, €18. From a family estate in the Treviso hills. Fresh pear and apple, perfect for a welcome drink.
- Marsuret 'Il Soller' Valdobbiadene Prosecco Superiore, €28.85. The Marsuret family have farmed the steep hills of Valdobbiadene since 1950. This is Prosecco at its finest: more depth, finer bubbles.
Which one, when?
- Christmas morning: Prosecco or Cava, light enough for breakfast.
- With smoked salmon: Crémant or Champagne. Their acidity cuts the oil.
- A big party: Cava or Prosecco, in quantity.
- The midnight toast on New Year's Eve: Champagne, and a magnum if you can.
- In a cocktail or punch: Cava. Save the Champagne for the glass.
Serving tips
- Chill to 6–8°C. Three hours in the fridge, or 20 minutes in an ice bucket with water and ice.
- Open it quietly. Hold the cork, twist the bottle, and let the pressure ease out with a sigh, not a pop. Point it away from people.
- Use a white-wine glass rather than a narrow flute. You'll smell much more of the wine.
- Keep it fizzy. A proper sparkling-wine stopper keeps traditional-method bubbles going for a day or two.
Sparkling wine: quick answers
What's the difference between Champagne and Crémant?
The place. Both are made the same way, but only wine from the Champagne region can be called Champagne.
Is Prosecco made like Champagne?
No. Prosecco gets its bubbles in a large tank rather than in each bottle, which keeps it fruity and fresh.
What's the best value alternative to Champagne?
Crémant. Same method, often about half the price.
How many glasses in a magnum?
Twelve to sixteen flutes.
For the rest of the meal, see our guide to wine with Christmas dinner, or browse all our sparkling wines.
Popping something on Christmas morning or at midnight on New Year's Eve? Take a photo and tag us @winesdirectirl. The last delivery day before Christmas is Monday 21 December.
Gav & Gareth Keogh, Wine Brothers | Wines Direct